The Lacuna: A Novel (P.S.)
:
Price : $16.99
Offer Price : $9.82
2010-07-15
By Cynthia K. Robertson (beverly, new jersey USA)
In reading Barbara Kingsolver's The Lacuna, I experienced a wide range of emotions. At times, I thought it was brilliant. Other times, it was tedious and boring. But throughout, it was beautifully written. The jury was out on this until the stunning ending, and it was then that I decided to rate this book 4 stars.
Harrison William Shepherd is 12 years old when his Mexican mother divorces his American father and they move to Mexico. Soleme' Shepherd is a kept woman and her son is forced to fend for himself. Shepherd is very smart, he loves to write and is a quick learner. When schooling fails, he finds work with the artists Frida Kahlo and her husband, Diego. At first he cooks, but when Trotsky takes exile with the Mexican artists, he becomes Trotsky's secretary. After Trotsky's murder, Shepherd moves back to the United States and decides to become a writer. However, his time with Trotsky will come back to haunt him as the McCarthy-era comes into play.
The Lacuna is told in diary form, along with letters and articles from current events of the time. There are also notes from Shepherd's assistant, Violet Brown. I found this confusing at first. I enjoyed reading about Kahlo and Trotsky. But I do have a problem when fictional characters are inserted into a historic work. Kingsolver's writing is beautiful and she's an artist with words. Kahlo explains art to Shepherd "These kids who come to Diego wanting to learn, I'll tell you. They can paint a perfect tree, a perfect face, whatever you ask. But they don't know enough about life to fill a thimble. And that's what has to go in the painting. Otherwise, why look at it?" Yet, many of the journal entries were understated and hinting. It was easy to miss important facts because they were mentioned so casually.
The Lacuna is an ambitious novel and Kingsolver has garnered many rave reviews. But many reviewers have panned this book as well. I can see where both camps are coming from.









